Wednesday, 4 August 2010

A historic summer for the PR profession

The summer of 2010 may be looked back on as rather significant in the development of public relations.  It has been a summer for Accords - for stating principles and definitions of PR practice.  First there was the Stockholm Accord which sought to define the practice of PR overall as part of the World Public Relations Forum.   This perhaps has not had the coverage it deserves but it is an important document on the role and value of PR within organisations and interpreting it in the language and issues facing today's global organisations.  It is a document for PR practitioners but also one which will be very helpful for other senior management professions and stakeholdes in understanding the role of PR.

This was followed in July by the Barcelona Declaration on measurement and evaluation.  The Declaration seeks to set down some broad principles for measurement and evaluation of PR and in particular the need from measuring outputs to outcomes.  It also fires a broadside at AVE, (Advertising Value Equivalents) which has been one of the key but generally discredited metrics used by practitioners in measuring outputs in the form of media coverage.  It also highlights the importance of measuring PR's impact on business results such as sales which as the Declaration highlights raises the issue of PR understanding the metrics used in marketing.  An interesting point which does highlight the interesting overlap between transactional relationships and stakeholder relationships which is at the heart of the marketing and PR ties.

Both are very interesting documents and statements which provide a useful point for practitioner, observers, students and academics.   They do show the growing confidence of the PR profession which the Stockholm Accords highlight and the need to articulate the progress they have made to the wider world.  Having briefly and enjoyably studied medieval history at A-Level, these Accords and Declaration by the PR world this summer, remind me somewhat of the great Councils and Edicts of the early Christian church as it sought to ensure that its authority and primacy of intepretation went unchallenged.  

Finally, and the subject of a future blog, it is entirely appropriate in such a summer that the University of Bournemouth has hosted the first International History of PR Conference.

Thursday, 17 June 2010

A Fistful of dollars - IMF report on role of lobbying in financial crash

I attended earlier in the week a very good workshop run by the University of Kingston in London on the financial crisis and the developing political and economic agendas for future financial market regulation.  I went to get additional context for a Financial PR course we are running on the new Masters PR programme at Greenwich starting in September.

The role of media and the influence of lobbying during the crisis was an interesting sub-text in the workshop.  In particular a recent report by the IMF titled A Fistful of dollars on the relationship between lobbying and risk taking by the sub-prime mortgage financial institutions on Wall St was explored.   Essentially the report highlighted that those financial institutions which lobbied most actively against any tightening of regulation in the sub-prime area by the authorities were also those who took the most risks, suffered the worst returns over time and were major recipients of the US government bailouts.

No PR or communication academics are quoted in the IMF report but they could have done as lobbying draws on PR frameworks in its approach to communications although particularly in the US has developed its own route of professionalisation.   Lobbying needs to consider the question raised by Larissa Grunig on the role of PR and quoted by Dejan Vercic "Are we in the business of persuasion? of information? of negotiation? of co-optation? of co-operation".   Perhaps it was better put by both Grunigs later (1992) as framed by two extremes; compliance gaining (asymmetry) and problem solving (symmetry).  Does lobbying do problem solving?  The IMF report is a damning indictment of the destructive role which lobbying can play when seeking compliance not to solve problems.   But the PR profession cannot ignore the wider lessons which the report raises.

Monday, 14 June 2010

BP, PR and Ashby's Law of Requisite Variety

Taking a view of BP's PR efforts on social media today compared with the first weeks and it is noticeable that Twitter is being much more actively used by BP than at the start as well as the company's Facebook BP America page.  The Facebook page is also taking in feeds from Twitter comments and commenting on them showing a growing understanding of the integration of the different services.

A comment from BP America's today (14th June) "We want our page to be an appropriate forum for everyone, and an exchange of constructive dialogue from differing opinions" highlights the developing conversation.  This was entirely absent in the first hours and days of the Gulf oil spill.

Tony Hayward, CEO of BP.

BP's PR effort on a range of counts has been heavily criticised.  The latest broadside was this weekend in the Financial Times although the article acknowledged that any company would have suffered major reputational damage over such an incident.  However the FT notably linked communications problems to wider organisational and cultural issues within BP over how it ran its American subsidiary.  In particular a failure to have a senior heavyweight management team run by Americans dealing with the US government and US media (as opposed to its very British-
centric team who have gone down badly) and included in this was the
fact, that BP also employs a British PR consultancy even for its US work, Brunswick. Other commentators have been more direct over Brunswick's failures and I would add that social media has also never been Brunswick's strength.

 Ross Ashby.  (Source: Principia Cybernetica.)

This lack of organisational and cultural sensitivity in BP brings us to one of the pioneers of systems theory, Ross Ashby.  A physciatrist and academic, Asbhy was famous for his work on Systems Theory and Cybernetics and influential to a generation of academics particularly in the (1960s) developing field of business and organisational strategy (not least PR's own Open Systems Theory).  His Law of Requisite Variety ( interpreting in organisational context), says that an organisation must have the capabilities (technical, managerial etc) and "variety" for the environment in which it operates.  The more complex the environment the more "variety" needed within the organisation.   On all these fronts BP has failed - and BP's communication performance is symptomatic of these failures.

Thursday, 13 May 2010

UK election - old media and new media - who was the winner?

There has been quite a debate in all forms of media about the role of mass media versus new media in the election.  Jon Snow summed up what many believe that online in the UK election has played a limited role compared with the Obama campaign, although he was writing during the campaign.  Reflecting on it after the  campaign what role did new media play?

Talking to Paul Simpson an active LibDem tweeter, and in the Top 30 Political UK tweeters (as well as a colleague at Greenwich) - he felt that Twitter did not have a great campaign and was used primarily by the parties to amplify messages with lots of aimless re-tweets, but not to develop discourse.  (Is Twitter losing some vibrancy generally?).  A good overview with links and a summary of the overall social media campaign is provided by eModeration which highlights the strong vote for the LibDems on the Facebook poll  where apparently over 400,000 took part.

One point which I don't think the commentators in mainstream media have made enough of, was the good turnout.  There was some talk in the run up to the campaign that there might be a low turnout in the 50s.  In fact the election achieved a UK turnout of 65%;  UK Electioninfo provides some good data on turnouts since 1945.  What is striking is that since 2001, turnout has been growing when it nearly went below 60%.  Are we seeing social media's influence in these figures and is Facebook combined with the impact of the TV debates perhaps the real winner for this campaign in energising young people and getting them out to vote?

Saturday, 1 May 2010

Crisis PR at BP

Watching how BP handles the major oil pollution incident off the US Gulf coast is going to be very instructive in terms of crisis PR.   The severity of the situation is immense, even for a company of BP's size and experience in crisis PR situations. It is also in a politically sensitive area just recovering from the effects of Hurricaine Katrina in 2005 which has given an added dimension to US coverage and that is an aspect which is somewhat different than many crisis PR situations facing organisations.

My impression is that after a slow start BP is starting to get its crisis PR team into action with mainstream media in the UK!   However the USA is another matter and social media also looks weak.  The comments on Twitter suggest an increasingly hostile reaction as more information comes out but also quizzical that BP does not appear to have an active policy of communicating across all channels of communication including Twitter.

Monday, 19 April 2010

Advertising agencies losing out on data primacy

Interesting perspective highlighted in today's Financial Times that advertising agencies may be losing out to increasingly digital savvy clients and also no longer seen as having access to key sources of data.  According to the Council of Marketing, the key data for organisations in terms of marketing and advertising is now primarily in-house such as web site traffic.  This trend is leading major companies according to the story to build their own resources in-house, draw on specialist IT suppliers and cut back on traditional agencies.  Another element in the move from mass media to interactive media and changing influence of the promotional disciplines.

Sunday, 14 March 2010

Citizen takeover gathers pace at United

The pace of developments at Manchester United continues to surprise.  It really is becoming a fascinating story about "ownership" of a brand and the legitimacy of ownership when the customers decide that the owners are not running the organisation in a responsible way.  Certainly it is showing the impact that an involved, committed and passionate community of users and consumers (brand community) can have around an established brand when they want greater involvement.   In the case of Manchester United it is no longer a question of shared ownership of the equity of the brand, which most assumed was the agenda with brand community, the fans are actually setting the agenda of ownership - they want to take control.   The coup of getting David Beckham to wear the green and yellow scarf was a symbolic moment and according to the Guardian, media around the world have covered this aspect of the story taking the story to another level.
(Photo from gulfnews.com)


The Guardian piece also suggests that the club have introduced a range of classic control measures on communictions which any PR consultant can tell them are useless.   The measures including firing any employee wearing the scarf and now they are editing out all mentions of the protest from United press conferences which are covered on its own TV station, MUTV.  That will be the first commercial activity which the protest group, MUST, will target, as the actions of the club are undermining the legitimacy of their own TV station. The owners if they are going to succeed will need to need to build a dialogue with the fans.  They cannot ignore the demands, can they build a compromise position where the fans have a larger stake, which surely is a position for the Glazers to consider?  I doubt they have the capability to develop such an agenda not least because football has traditionally shown little understanding of the role of public relations in contrast to marketing as academics such as Maria Hopwood from Leeds Met highlighted at the CIPR Academic Conference at the University of Stirling in the summer.   

The importance of symbols in the campaign is particularly interesting both in terms of brands but also their historical pedigree.   Beckham wearing the scarf and so symbolising - even anointing its significance - to the whole role of the scarf in its different colours from the traditional brand have a powerful resonance.  All revolutions - or citizen takeovers - have icons, something which Wally Olins, a leading corporate identity  practitioner and commentator, has highlighted in several papers highlighting the use of icons in the French revolution (tricolor, Marseillaise etc).
(Delacroix: Liberty leading the people. 1830. Britannia.com)